What is the difference between a Bushhog and a Forestry Mulcher?
- ShadowCat sold our Bushhog attachment as it could not compete with the Forestry Mulcher in efficiency or quality of results. We are happy to explain the differences however so you can decide what you need!
- As for the difference, it's in the name and it's in the price of the equipment!
- The average Bushhog attachment cost from $3,000 and top out at around $10,000. A Forestry Mulcher attachment STARTS at over $30,000 for the attachment!!! A set of teeth for the forestry mulcher costs $3000, or almost the same as a Bushhog itself. That is one reason you see many Bushhog operators but few Forestry Mulchers.
- Blades on a bushhog cost $40 each and there are only three of them. Teeth on a forestry mulcher cost $90 each and there are thirty teeth! That is the second reason you see many Bushhog operators but few Forestry Mulchers. The replacement teeth alone over the course of a year of operation will cost more than the the purchase price of any bushhog attachment.
- A Bushhog primarily is used for tall grass and small bushes. You see farm tractors on side of the road cutting grass... they are pulling a bushhog. Bushhogs can also be pushed, such as my bushhog picture shown below. However, a bushhog cannot mulch, nor can they handle palmettos or larger brush and trees! Bushhogs are three bladed mowers, similar to a lawn mower so they are limited in performance and quality of results. They can cut down small 1-2 inch diameter trees but you will have large pieces everywhere vs mulch. Bushhog manufacturers claim to be able to cut through up to 12 inch trees... this is false. My Diamond bushhog was limited to around five inch diameter trees (cutting, not mulching) and the results are horrible, even though Diamond claims to be able to cut down a 12 inch tree. The Diamond bushhog is one of the largest bushhogs and cost over $10,000... so compare that with people using $4,000 bushhogs and you can expect even poorer results.
- A Forestry mulcher is used to mulch bushes, small trees, palmetto plants, general overgrowth, etc. Forestry mulchers are great at mulching up to six inch diameter tress. They can go higher, but the reality is that is more marketing by the manufacturer than actual function. To mulch larger trees would simply be a waste of your money vs cutting them down with a chain saw and having them hauled away. It is a simple matter of Scale of Economics... larger trees wear out the teeth of the mulcher much faster, which then requires replacement teeth, which means more cost to the customer to offset operating costs! Stay six inches or below with a mulcher, use a chainsaw above six inches. While a bushhog cannot handle palmettos, a forestry mulcher slices through palmettos without a problem. Typical Florida overgrowth is no match for a Forestry Mulcher and the pictures in my Before/After galleries are all from Forestry mulching. Pepper trees, palmettos, medium size trees, etc are all Forestry mulcher only type of growth.
A Forestry Mulcher also can only be operated by a large machine with high flow hydraulics. Smaller machines simply do not have the power to lift the attachment or run it at proper speeds.
Below are pictures for comparison... Notice even a bigger machine was needed to run the forestry mulcher!
A Forestry Mulcher vs Bushhog on same thick overgrowth is no match! Below is a picture showing the results of processing the same 6 foot tall scrub oaks and typical Florida overgrowth. The property owner had hired a bushhog operator to clear the land first and was unhappy with the results (left side of picture) and then hired ShadowCat to finish the job and clean up the bushhog's mess. The right side of the below picture shows the results of a Forestry mulcher clearing same overgrowth. Bushhogs just cut and throw material that is larger than grass or small bushes. Bushhogs are fine for grass and small bushes but cannot handle thicker material as shown which would include sapling trees, palmettos, thick bushes, bamboo, etc
The bushhog operator should never have attempted this job and that is where experience of the operator comes into play. Know the capabilities of the machine and results that can be generated. In my bushhog picture above you can see the light bush and grass in the background I cleared and left the tree line alone even though small trees. The property the forestry mulcher picture is from above can also be seen in the Before and After gallery showing what the property looked like before.
Do I need a permit to clear my property?
- Most counties allow property owners to clear overgrowth without a permit. Depending on the county, overgrowth is generally defined as all brush and small trees up to three or four inches in diameter. Palmettos and other invasive species do not require permits. Always check with your city/county for specifics!
- Any large trees will generally require permits to take down unless zoned agriculture. These should be removed by a licensed Tree Service company. ShadowCat can refer you to legitimate Tree Service companies once you are at the point of removing big trees.
Always verify any business you may use is listed as Active on sunbiz.org otherwise they are not an official business in the State of Florida and are unlicensed, uninsured, and will just be more trouble than lower cost may provide.
What is the correct order I should do the work in to acheieve desired results?
- In general, clearing the overgrowth should always be done first! Mainly for three reasons:
- Access: Clearing all the overgrowth allows for access across the property.
- Safety: Clearing the overgrowth creates a safer environment for you and other contractors who follow ShadowCat at later dates by removing snake habitat as well as potential hazards such as sharp sticks, stumps, etc that could injure people or damage equipment.
- Cost: By removing overgrowth, you eliminate the surcharge other companies will add to their service for working in thick overgrowth. They have to account for injuries, snake bites, damage to equipment and such when they cannot see the hazards in the area they are working in, so taking away the overgrowth takes away the extra cost they will charge!
What is the difference between Root Raking and Stump Removal and when should I do either?
- Root Raking: Root raking is the process in which a rake (grapple claw attachment) is stuck approximately six inches into the ground and then driven forward through the dirt to pull up miscellaneous tree and bush roots. Depth can be shallower or deeper as needed depending on what is growing in the area.
- Stump Removal: Stump Removal, unlike Stump Grinding, is the total removal of the stump and it's roots from an area. Stump Grinding can be done by ShadowCat as well depending on your needs.
- When to do: When to do either of these methods is a personal choice for the most part, but sometimes is dictated by your plans for the property. If you are building a house, metal storage building, or driveway you MUST remove all large roots and stumps. If a foundation is poured over stumps and large roots, cracks will develop as the organic material decays underneath the cement.
If you are planning on running horses on the property, you should completely root raking in all areas the horses will run. Root raking will remove all stumps and large roots that can lead to a horse breaking a leg so spend the extra time and money to protect your horse!
If the area being cleared will remain more of an open space with no specific use, do your wallet a favor and skip the root raking process!
Below are pictures of the Root Rake/Grapple Claws (left picture) and the Stump Puller (right picture) attachments.